Order the summer edition here

Immigration as a means of payment for the sins of the West

TIME OF SETTLEMENT / Why should migrants "respect our borders"? The West never respected theirs. Immigration quotas should be based on how much the West has destroyed other countries.


These days it is being debated USA owes its African American citizens a replacement for slavery. It did. But Europe and the United States have a far greater bill to fall: what they owe to other countries for their "adventures" in the colonies, for the wars they have inflicted on them, for the inequality they have introduced into the world order, and not least for the climate emissions they have charged the atmosphere with.

Credit countries do not seriously suggest that Vest annually send sacks of gold money to India or Nigeria in compensation. What their people are asking for is justice: that the borders of the rich countries are opened to goods and people, be it Indian textiles or Nigerian doctors. They ask for immigration as a substitute.

Today, a quarter of a billion people migrants. They move because rich countries have stolen the future of the poor countries. Whether it is Iraqis and Syrians fleeing the consequences of illegal US wars, or Africans seeking employment with their former colonial powers, or Guatemalans and Hondurans trying to enter the country who supplied them with weapons and bought their drugs: They will come to the West because we've been with them.

Before you ask them to respect our borders, ask yourself: Has the West ever respected anyone's borders?

immigration Quotas

A large majority of migrants do not move to a rich country, but to a less poor country. Immigration quotas should be proportionate to how much the host country has destroyed other countries. The UK should have quotas for Indians and Nigerians, France for Malaysians and Tunisians, Belgium for Congolese people. And when the migrants arrive in the host country, they should be allowed to take the family with them and stay – unlike the "guest workers" who were lured to build up the much needed workforce of the colonial powers and then asked to go back when there was no need them more.

The Dominican Republic should be high on the US quota list; the Americans supported the Dominican dictator Rafael Trujillo for thirty years. The same goes for Iraq, where the United States inflicted a war on the country that resulted in 600 deaths. In the name of justice, the United States should now receive as many Iraqis; For every death we caused there, someone should have the opportunity to start a new life in the United States.

About 12 million Africans were taken as slaves and transported across the Atlantic. Shouldn't 12 million Africans be allowed to live in the lands that were enriched at the expense of their ancestors? Both parties will benefit from this: Africans will continue to suffer from what slavery did to their homeland, and the host country will once again gain the benefit of African labor – but this time it can happen without pain and a fair wage.

Just as the polluting industry has to pay environmental taxes, it should be an "immigrant tax" for nations that have enriched themselves through greenhouse gas emissions.

The United States is responsible for about a third of emissions, Europe a quarter. Hundreds of millions climate refugees – fleeing hurricanes and droughts – must find a new place to live during this century. The United States should receive a third of them, Europe a quarter.

Although the bill may seem high, it is a bill the West should look forward to paying. Without immigration, US economic growth would have been 15 percent lower in the period 1990–2014; growth in the UK would have been 20 per cent lower.

Should not 12 million Africans be allowed to live in the countries that enriched themselves
ancestral expense?

Immigrants make up 14 percent of the population of the United States, but they account for a quarter of all new businesses in the United States and, since 2000, have received one-third of the Nobel Prize the United States has been awarded in the fields of chemistry, physics and medicine.

Migrants make up 3 percent of the world's population, but contribute 9 percent of GDP (gross domestic product). Their contribution to the tax bill helps to fund the pension schemes of rich nations who are unable to give birth to enough children themselves.

Open borders

If we really want to help the world poor, the fastest and most effective method is this: to make immigration easier. Migrants provided us with $ 689 billion in money transfers last year, which is 3 times more than the direct gain from eliminating trade barriers, 4 times more than all non-aid and 100 times the debt cancellation amount.

Are wealthy countries in the West obliged to welcome all who come from lands they have plundered?

There are compelling arguments against open borders: that the United States is a lifeboat in a sea of ​​poor nations, and that too many immigrants want the boat to sink. That even if we owe these people a compensation, the damages can be made by cash settlement or settlement on another territory.

There are no serious arguments proving long-term economic harm to countries receiving immigrants, not even when immigration assumes large proportions. During the mass migration, a quarter of Europe's population moved to the United States, which then took over Europe's pallet placement in wealth and power.

A world with (more) open borders will experience a short period of mass migration, but then migration can actually slow down, as money and happiness will be more equitably distributed and more people will want to stay where they are.

To avoid paying an "immigration tax", the rich countries will stop supporting dictators, not start more barbaric wars, limit multinational corporations 'exploitation of poor countries' mineral resources and ensure fairer global trade. If not, the "migration bill" from the ruined country will be prohibitive.

What is good (and economical) immigration for the United States, is separate from what is just and morally right for migrants whose fate has affected: It may seem more financially reasonable for the United States to hire skilled people than unskilled labor from Latin America, but the Americans owe the latter more and should open the doors of their neighbors to the south.

History is what everything has happened, and it can never be changed; but the story also happens in the here and now. We need to be aware of this, and ready to pay the bill.

Mehta is the author of This Land is Our Land: An Immigrant's Manifesto. The book has recently been translated by Erik Ringen and published in Norwegian: entitled This country is also ours (Res Publica). The chronicle was under pressure in the New York Times last year.

Translated by Iril Kolle

- self-advertisement -

Recent Comments:

Siste artikler

Iconic paintings and photographs

Role models: In public Latin America, independence heroes Bolívar and San Martin or Che Guevara and Evita are either idolized or satanized through paintings and photographs. This book takes a closer look at why.

Permanent state of emergency

ESSAY: The power goes out, exchange rates fluctuate, bread prices explode, fuel disappears. There are also still traces of the explosion. Yet Beirut's hard-pressed citizens time and again manage to find a foothold in chaos. And the chaos is contributing to Beirut never becoming a clean-up city.

Muslim elites, exercise of power and terror

AFRICA: What can a book say about Boko Haram or the porous border between today's Cameroon and today's Chad? Or about the pre-colonial kingdom of Kanem-Bornu?

The limits of our way of life

FUTURE: Environmental disasters, global warming, crisis of civilization and planetary apocalypse have given rise to ideas about the doom of the earth and the end of time. Through a radical anthropology, a couple of authors make an attempt to restore our faith in the world.

Agamben: A burning house

PHILOSOPHY: Italian Giorgio Agamben describes and envisions different courses for our thinking than today's more technologically nihilistic will-driven production paradigm. Two books delve into other possibilities than the 'fire' he believes we find ourselves in. In this essay, Astrid Nordang tries to bring out some of this complicated material.

A good life without more and more of everything

GREEN GROWTH: MODERN TIMES has chosen to print an extract from the book Grønt manifesto by our regular critic. "Quality of life rather than forced growth": Three small but powerful words, which provide a key to changing the direction of social development, where our eternal pursuit of 'the most possible' is rather adjusted to the appreciation of 'adequate'.

End Times Thoughts

PHILOSOPHY: While postmodernism involved an explosion, today's posthumous condition, according to Marina Garcés, involves a liquidation of all possibilities – an implosion. Yes, are the hopes we cling to today just market-adapted needs for hope?

Camille, Hannah, Lisa, Pauline and Flora

WOMEN: Art done by men is simply given more attention: in collections, in exhibition programs, in art literature, in the art market. But what about the large number of female artists over the past 500 years?

I was completely out of the world

Essay: The author Hanne Ramsdal tells here what it means to be put out of action – and come back again. A concussion leads, among other things, to the brain not being able to dampen impressions and emotions.

Silently disciplining research

PRIORITIES: Many who question the legitimacy of the US wars seem to be pressured by research and media institutions. An example here is the Institute for Peace Research (PRIO), which has had researchers who have historically been critical of any war of aggression – who have hardly belonged to the close friends of nuclear weapons.

Is Spain a terrorist state?

SPAIN: The country receives sharp international criticism for the police and the Civil Guard's extensive use of torture, which is never prosecuted. Regime rebels are imprisoned for trifles. European accusations and objections are ignored.

Is there any reason to rejoice over the coronary vaccine?

COVID-19: There is no real skepticism from the public sector about the coronary vaccine – vaccination is recommended, and the people are positive about the vaccine. But is the embrace of the vaccine based on an informed decision or a blind hope for a normal everyday life?

The military commanders wanted to annihilate the Soviet Union and China, but Kennedy stood in the way

Military: We focus on American Strategic Military Thinking (SAC) from 1950 to the present. Will the economic war be supplemented by a biological war?


Bjørnboe: In this essay, Jens Bjørneboe's eldest daughter reflects on a lesser – known psychological side of her father.

Arrested and put on smooth cell for Y block

Y-Block: Five protesters were led away yesterday, including Ellen de Vibe, former director of the Oslo Planning and Building Agency. At the same time, the Y interior ended up in containers.

A forgiven, refined and anointed basket boy

Pliers: The financial industry takes control of the Norwegian public.

Michael Moore's new film: Critical to alternative energy

EnvironmentFor many, green energy solutions are just a new way to make money, says director Jeff Gibbs.

The pandemic will create a new world order

Mike Davis: According to activist and historian Mike Davis, wild reservoirs, like bats, contain up to 400 types of coronavirus that are just waiting to spread to other animals and humans.

The shaman and the Norwegian engineer

cohesion: The expectation of a paradise free of modern progress became the opposite, but most of all, Newtopia is about two very different men who support and help each other when life is at its most brutal.

Skinless exposure

Anorexia: shameless uses Lene Marie Fossen's own tortured body as a canvas for grief, pain and longing in her series of self portraits – relevant both in the documentary self Portrait and in the exhibition Gatekeeper.