Subscription 790/year or 195/quarter

When propaganda took over the schools

Mr Nobody Against Putin
RUSSIA / How a small-town teaching assistant became a whistleblower about the grim reality of war propaganda.




(THIS ARTICLE IS MACHINE TRANSLATED by Google from Norwegian)

If you watch one documentary this year, it should be Mr Nobody Against Putin. Pavel Talankin's deeply moving – and disturbing – account of how Russian schools and the Russiane society succumbed to Putins military death cult as soon as the invasion of Ukraine was initiated in February 2022 – is both touching and heartbreaking.

Russia's most polluted city

Pavel – as his friends call him “Pasha” – is a 33-year-old teaching assistant at a school in the small town of Karabash in the Urals, known as Russia’s most polluted city, where copper mining waste has turned the surrounding hills black and toxic gases leak from rusty pipes into the streets.

But for Pasha, a self-proclaimed loner who has always felt like an outsider in Karabash, although he is beloved by his students, the city is a place of love and romance. For him, the tired, gray and stained five-story Soviet Khrushchevkas that house the city's residents are places of beauty – with the tangled pipelines of the copper mines, visions of beauty under the crisp, azure winter skies, when temperatures can drop to minus 40 degrees Celsius.

He may be an odd loner, but his job as a videographer tasked with filming all academic, student-related, and social events at the school he attended (and where his plump, slightly grumpy, but lovable mother works as a librarian) places him at the center of a small community where students flock to his small office, a place he calls a haven of democracy in a country that has gone mad.

Pasha's work – and his obsession with recording everything on tape, even his own admissions about lonely evenings in the two-room apartment he shares with his dog Nebraska and around 400 carefully color-coded books – forms the basis for a stunning directorial debut, shaped and supported by Copenhagen-based American documentarian, director and screenwriter David Borenstein.

Via a request on social media for someone willing to reveal militarizerThe gene of Russian education in the wake of the invasion of Ukraine – this is developing into a risky but purposeful project to do something to expose the wave of hatred that is embracing Russian society. All the while Putin's propaganda creates a victim complex in a country whose army brings unimaginable misery and violence to its neighbor.

Collective madness

Pasha's gradual awakening to the horror of living in a society descending into collective madness – all under the guise of Soviet patriotism – is woven into his everyday recording of teachingshoals where teachers are asked to read prepared texts accusing Ukrainian “neo-Nazis” of threatening Russia. And where a gray-faced history teacher mentions Lavrenty Beria – Stalin’s murderous head of the secret police – as one of his favorite historical figures.

If you watch one documentary this year, it should be Mr Nobody Against Putin.

He forges deep emotional bonds with many of his students. His fellow teachers tolerate his idiosyncrasies—like overlooking the fact that one morning at school assembly he played Lady Gaga's Biden inauguration rendition of "The Star Spangled Banner" instead of the required Russian anthem "Glinka." Also, that he gets away with a little forefinger when removing sticky notes with Z-symbol on the school windows to replace them with Xs, which is an online code for support for Ukraine – reflects Pasha’s perception of Karabash as a fundamentally decent place.

But as government interference in the curriculum increases at a rapid pace – with teaching in grenade throwing and weapon identification, visits by mercenaries from Wagner groups and the creation of a new patriotic youth movement in the style of Young Pioneers – Pasha feels forced to quit his job.

It is only then that he is contacted by Borenstein's team – who have somehow learned that he is willing to expose the militaristic turn in Russian politics. utdanning – that Pasha finds a new purpose. He withdraws his resignation and commits himself to meticulously documenting what happens when totalitarianism and its usual death cult grip a nation.

He removes stickers with the Z symbol on the school windows to replace them with Xs, which are a web code for support for Ukraine

Life in Karabash is getting worse, with young men being drafted, sent to the front, and often returning in coffins. The funeral scene of Pasha's friend Artyom – now too dangerous to film – is made all the more poignant and terrifying by the soundtrack that highlights the terrible wails of a grieving mother.

Another side of Russia

Finally, the time has come for Pasha to leave Russia for his own safety, and he makes a bold departure that reveals the quiet courage of a man with a conscience.

This is a sensitive, honest and beautifully filmed film. Pasha acknowledges that his suffering and the suffering of his friends, who lost loved ones in the war, cannot be compared to that of the Ukrainians. But the fact that he shows another side of Russia – that of people who experienced freedom for three short decades – rather than the hatred that Putin preaches – makes this an important film that is both a glimmer of light in a dark time and an important document for future historians.



Follow editor Truls Lie on X(twitter) or Telegram

Nick Holdsworth
Nick Holdsworth
Holdsworth is a writer, journalist and filmmaker.

You may also likeRELATED
Recommended

Lies, luxury and endless war

CORRUPTION: Alexis Bloom's gripping exposé of the web of lies that Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has apparently woven to avoid corruption charges shows how one man's fear of prison has led to war and instability in the Middle East. It's about a man whose ego has grown to the point where he sees himself as a kind of King David figure leading the Jewish people to salvation.

Working for peace

GAZA: The conflict in Gaza is horrific for all innocent people. But what enables an Israeli family to muster the political will and pressure to have their daughter released within two months, while thousands of Palestinians who were arrested and imprisoned without charge or trial during the war remain voiceless?

Seeds are politics and big business

FOOD: The main theme of this film is the hybridization of seeds, using the tomato plant as an example. The point of hybridizing seeds is increased yield and increased profits. The companies behind it are Bayer (Monsanto), Corteva (formerly DuPont) and Syngenta.

The unfulfilled promises of decolonization

REVOLUTION: This film shows the untold stories of the female FLN fighters in Algeria and their erasure from history after independence. And the promises of reforms and equality were hollow.

An adventure of a documentary

activism: Once upon a Time in a Forest is a documentary packed with fine photographic details – such as small close-ups of strily lichen and old man's beard, bark and cuckoos. But also strong portraits of some very wise young forest activists in Finland – who believe that more forests must be protected.

The impact of the NATO base on the local community

ITALY: In this film, do we witness a nuclear family's 'high-tech' dissolution? The immersive Sicilian nature reserve is disturbed…